• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Pearson Communications

Law Firm Communications Consultant

  • Services
  • Lloyd Pearson
  • Blog
  • Contact

September 15, 2014

How Do Lawyers Respond To Rankings?

Although this video – “How your brain responds to performance rankings” – is about internal staff performance measurement, there are some parallels with the legal industry’s fixation on surveys and rankings, whether it’s the much discussed US News law school rankings, or the myriad of individual attorney “best”, “super” and “band one” lists .

The video summarizes research from the NeuroLeadership Institute, an international research association dedicated to the neuroscience of leadership.

Although I disagree with the view expressed in the video that numerical rankings and rating scales don’t work per se – I think they are inevitable to help us make sense of an information-soaked world – I have often wondered about the psychological impact of rankings on those being ranked, about whether – as the narrator suggests – if you are categorized as a “two”, there is a permanence to that and you will always be a two and always see yourself as a two.

“Numerical labeling generates the same fight or flight response that occurs in the brain when there is a physical threat, priming people for rapid reactions and aggressive movements.”

The report maintains that this response would be suitable for survival if being attacked by a wild animal, but in a modern business setting, doesn’t produce the thoughtful learning needed to improve performance.

“Rankings lead to frustration, less willingness to take risks, and colleagues working against each other.”

My take-away from this video is that a straight numerical ranking, while helpful for consumers or businesses and those seeking to quickly differentiate between lawyers, may not necessarily produce the desired response in the lawyer themselves, or enable the lawyer to improve their service.

Perhaps more nuanced ranking systems are what’s required?

(Richard Tromans, a legal consultant, first shared this video on LinkedIn)

Share the post "How Do Lawyers Respond To Rankings?"

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Email

Filed Under: Legal Awards, Legal Directories, Legal Marketing, Legal Surveys

By Lloyd Pearson

Legal directories consultant serving law firms worldwide.

Contact me

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Victoria says

    September 16, 2014 at 2:40 pm

    I fully agree with you that rankings is far from the best measurements – it makes people feel afraid, not sure of themselves and it doesn’t count any of the special cases and situations- meaning oyu can not precisely count how complicated the case was

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Recent Posts

  • Lawdragon 2024 Global 100 Leaders in Legal Strategy & Consulting
  • Abry Partners Takes Over Chambers & Partners From Inflexion
  • Improve Legal Directory Submissions With Active Sentences
  • Lawdragon Names World’s Top 100 Legal Consultants for 2022
  • New Private Equity Firm Comes in for Best Lawyers

Tags

Above The Law AccessSolicitor Acritas ALM American Lawyer Avvo Benchmark Awards Benchmark Litigation Best Lawyers Bloomberg British Legal Awards BTI Chambers & Partners Euromoney FindLaw FT Innovative Lawyers IFLR IFLR1000 Incisive Media International Law Office Internet Brands Law360 Law Business Research LawDingo Lawdragon Law Firm Media Professionals LawPath Lawyers.Com Legal 500 Legal Business Legalease Legal Marketing Association Legal Media Group Legal Week Lexis Nexis Lexpert Martindale-Hubbell National Law Journal Nolo Practical Law Company RSG Consulting Super Lawyers The Lawyer Thomson Reuters US News

Footer

Contact

lloyd@pearsoncomms.com

About

Legal industry communications consultant

Follow

  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2025 · Barlow Ridge Ltd · All Rights Reserved